Monday, July 14, 2025

Retirement Village Residents Fighting Back

 Housing for the Aged Action Group posted the following details - 

Not just unfair, unlawful: VCAT rules against village charging Deferred Management Fees

Housing for the Aged Action Group welcomes a decision from VCAT President Justice Woodward which found that the Residential Tenancies Act prevented a land lease village from charging Deferred Management Fees (DMFs). DMFs are a common kind of exit fee charged across several types of retirement housing, often costing departing residents or their families tens of thousands of dollars or more.

“We have long said that these DMFs are unfair and, in some cases, unlawful,” said Shane McGrath, HAAG’s Senior Tenancy and Retirement Worker. “This decision confirms that some of the most common models for DMFs in land lease communities are prohibited under Victorian law.”

Click here for the full story - https://www.oldertenants.org.au/publications/not-just-unfair-unlawful-vcat-rules-against-village-charging-deferred-management-fees

Saturday, April 5, 2025

Retirement Village Rip-Off

 The Jacinta Allan Labor government 2025 Victorian Retirement Villages Act perpetuates the rip-off of charging a purchase price without gaining ownership, only occupancy in a retirement village. VOTE NO.

retirement village rip-off


Friday, April 4, 2025

 Currently Victorian retirement village residents wait 6 months for repayment of their refundable amount on leaving a village. The Jacinta Allan Labor government has pushed that out to 12. Why? Only 1 winner the operators pockets. Elderly Victorians lose, what do they live on, how do they go forward.

retiree repayment from 6 months out to 12 months


Sunday, March 30, 2025

What is wrong with Victorian Retirement Villages

The critical importance of retirement village resident submissions to Victorian state government inquiries is that they are actually living the experience not simply 'working in the field'. They know what is wrong because they have experienced it, suffered from it.

Victorian retirement village residents find that there is almost zero protection when something goes wrong, or the system to obtain that protection is so cumbersome, so demanding on them, that surrender is ultimately the chosen option. And village operators know that and use it to their own financial advantage.

All this from a Victorian Labor government that fails to enforce the law as it is currently written, let alone to improve it to protect the very people it was originally written to protect.

"The law was clearly on the side of the village residents. It was a lack of access to affordable, quick, decisive enforcement of the law that failed them most". - Retvilldotnet

Retirement villages, the process of for-profit operators seeking financial reward from this commercial activity under the guise of the provision of benevolent housing for older Victorians. Sadly and particularly in Victoria the commercial risks to operators are dampened by statute whilst at the same time the commercial rewards are enhanced by statute. 

For Victorian retirees who make that fateful decision to enter a retirement village it is the complete opposite. The payment of the capital value of the village unit, not for ownership simply occupancy. The payment of all the costs of property ownership with none of the rewards.

"Families need to be aware that what we are talking about here is the transfer of intergenerational wealth, not to families but into the pockets of corporations. Shame about the elderly not having enough money for aged care."

So what is wrong with Victorian Retirement villages, the answer is -

  1. Bureaucrats who don't really know or fully understand the product they are producing legislation for.
  2. Legislators who don't really know or fully understand the product they are enacting legislation for.
  3. State Governments who are far too easily seduced by slick marketing from the industry.
  4. A failure of all of the three parties above to listen to the one group of people who really do know and fully understand the product, the village residents and their families. 
Village residents understand because they suffer financially from the legislative inequities produced by Bureaucrats, Legislators, State Governments.


retirement village poverty trap






Wednesday, February 5, 2025

Intergenerational Capital Wealth Lost

Transfer of Capital Wealth

Retirement Village Residents Get Trampled